English label Sounds of Yesteryear's
The Genius of George Gershwin is a two-disc collection of historical recordings of
Gershwin's music made between 1918 and 1931, though most of it is concentrated in the years 1926-1928. The first disc,
George Gershwin at the Piano, contains many to most of the studio recordings that
Gershwin made as a pianist, although it does not include the recordings he made as accompanist to
Fred and
Adele Astaire and does include
Nat Shilkret's 1929 waxing of "An American in Paris," a date to which
Gershwin only made a minimal contribution. The second disc is titled
The Bands Play George Gershwin, and includes a wide variety of 1920s and early-'30s jazz and dance orchestras playing songs from various
Gershwin shows. Many of the groups heard in this part of the collection are English, which sets it apart from similarly themed domestic U.S. collections of this kind. The transfers are very quiet, but a little constricted and below par for such reissues; however, listeners who cannot bear even the slightest trace of 78-rpm surface noise will be more than satisfied. It is an inexpensive collection, and the cheap-looking generic cover graphic might be a little off-putting to advanced
Gershwin collectors; it makes it look like this is collection of faceless, anonymous orchestrations of
Gershwin standards that no one would want. Nevertheless, the inclusion of such gems as
the Savoy Orpheans' version of "Fascinating Rhythm" or
Nat Shilkret's 1931 take on the
Gershwin rarity "Delishious" may well make Sounds of Yesteryear's
The Genius of George Gershwin desirable, even if one already has the contents of the first disc many times over.
–
Uncle Dave Lewis, Rovi