Like margarine to butter, NutraSweet to sugar,
Sammy is to
Pavement -- a smoother, blander version of a classic.
Sammy distills the half-mumbled, half-sung vocals, loopy guitars, off-kilter percussion, and sunny pop hooks that
Pavement made their own in the late '80s, and slavish imitators that they are,
Sammy can't even chart the heights that
Pavement reaches. That said,
Sammy's major-label debut,
Tales of Great Neck Glory, is a fun, if derivative, album. Singer
Jesse Hartman has a cheeky, knowing style on songs like "Neptune Ave. (Ortho Hi Rise)" and "Blue Oyster Bay" that makes the group's five-finger discount style of songwriting enjoyable as a sort of in-joke between
Sammy and their audience. "Horse or Ballet?" and "Chilling Excerpts" in particular have a weird, jittery energy of their own, while "Buckle-Up Sunshine" lives up to its name, showing that the members of
Sammy are moving away from being merely competent copyists to something more interesting. While they may not be the real thing yet,
Sammy and
Tales of Great Neck Glory provide some mindlessly entertaining listening.
–
Heather Phares, Rovi