Capitol Records launched a midline-priced series called
Classic Masters and the 2002 entry for
Grand Funk Railroad is meant to appeal to the casual fan. It is intended to replace 1991's
Capitol Collectors Series title -- an earlier budget line from the label -- although track-wise it's identical except for one song. Both have 15 cuts, but
Classic Masters includes "Take Me" whereas
Capitol Collectors Series has "Inside Looking Out." Looking back, it's amazing to realize just how enormously popular these Michigan hard-rockers were in the late '60s and early '70s. For
Grand Funk Railroad, popular meant populist blue-collar appeal, and vocalist/guitarist
Mark Farner, bass guitarist
Mel Schacher, and drummer/vocalist
Don Brewer (and, later on, keyboardist
Craig Frost) were despised by critics, of course. The merits of anthems like "We're an American Band," "I'm Your Captain/Closer to Home," and the cover "The Loco-Motion" are obvious, but a compilation such as
Classic Masters enables deeper appreciation of songs like "Time Machine," "Shinin' On," "Mean Mistreater" (recorded live in 1970 at the Atlanta International Pop Festival), and "Bad Time."
Classic Masters is 24-bit digitally remastered, whereas
Capitol Collectors Series is credited as being mastered from the original two-track stereo mixes;
Classic Masters should be considered the superior collection sound-wise (although it's not as if
Grand Funk Railroad's records were as sonically complex as
Pink Floyd's), but
Capitol Collectors Series has better liner notes. Capitol is to be commended for its overdue CD reissues of
Grand Funk Railroad's catalog, but
Classic Masters is an excellent sampler die-hard fans like Homer Simpson would approve of.
–
Bret Adams, Rovi