Shelly Manne and
Norman Granz are two names that one doesn't hear in the same sentence very often.
Granz's
Jazz at the Philharmonic tours tended to have a lot of flashy solos, and
Manne wasn't about flashiness; he was a subtle drummer who knew the value of economy. Nonetheless,
Granz admired
Manne's playing -- and even though
Manne had reservations about taking part in
J.A.T.P.,
Granz managed to persuade him to join
J.A.T.P. on a tour of Europe in 1960. Recorded in Zurich, Switzerland, and Copenhagen, Denmark,
Yesterdays finds
Manne leading a diverse yet cohesive quintet that also includes trumpeter
Joe Gordon, tenor saxophonist
Richie Kamuca, pianist
Russ Freeman, and bassist
Monty Budwig. The performances on this CD went unreleased for 43 years, but in 2003, they finally saw the light of day when Fantasy released them on
Granz's Pablo label. Although
Manne made many valuable contributions to cool jazz, he didn't play with cool musicians exclusively -- unlike many of the New York jazz critics who loved to bash cool jazz in the '50s and '60s, he wasn't a narrow-minded dogmatist.
Manne was smart enough to realize that cool jazz and hard bop were equally valid areas of the house that
Charlie Parker built; as a result, he saw no reason why a cool-toned,
Lester Young-influenced improviser like
Kamuca couldn't have a rapport with
Gordon (a big-toned trumpeter along the lines of
Clifford Brown and
Fats Navarro). In fact,
Manne and his colleagues have no problem finding common ground on standards that include "Poinciana,"
Milt Jackson's "Bags' Groove," and
Thelonious Monk's "Straight, No Chaser." Although enjoyable,
Yesterdays isn't as essential as other
Manne discs that were recorded in the early '60s; nonetheless, the drummer's more devoted fans will welcome the arrival of these previously unreleased performances.
–
Alex Henderson, Rovi